So, this is It. What Are We Gonna Do?

I’m going to rename my Substack from I Hope I’m Wrong to something like: So, this is It. What Are We Gonna Do? The reason is that we may have just entered one of the few non-violent pathways out of authoritarianism—if we play our cards right. Back in March, I predicted that we’d be in a contested election right now, and thankfully I was proven wrong. See? I really did believe in my Substack’s former title.* I had also predicted that this MAGA regime would not cede power peacefully, and I’m still not so certain which way that will go, but there are some pretty unforeseen options in the mix, and with continued momentum, they may well be forced to leave peacefully. But in my view, there are no guarantees, and without sustained pressure from the public, the likelihood diminishes fast.

We just knocked the MAGA regime and its entire movement on their back heels, and now a full-on knockout requires the Democratic Party to do something it hasn’t done in over half a century. So the new fight is pressuring them, or rather, the establishment that has squandered every opportunity like this since 1974. I’m not going to give you a history lesson on how the New Deal transformed America, or how that transformation, along with the Civil Rights Movement and the Women’s Rights Movement, brought us to finally resembling a Democracy. If you read my stuff, you’re probably sick and tired of hearing about it. Blah, blah, blah, New Deal this, New Deal that, c’mon Duh Gioia. So I’ll just say, once again, that since 1974 we haven’t repeated the kind of truly transformational gains that the New Deal Democrats were able to bring about after the Great Depression—the last time we were confronted with the kind of wealth disparity we see now, only then, the divide was much less than it is today. And in this moment, our government is more beholden to corporate power than probably any other time in our history.

And that, in essence, is our problem, our core impediment to making a better world for all of us. I can’t hope I’m wrong about that fact, because I’m not. Oh, wait, I don’t have to play with that phrase anymore, never mind. So that’s a great segue to the Democratic establishment: why have they squandered every opportunity since 1974? Because they’ve been playing footsie with corporate America, that’s a cute way of saying they let themselves get bought. None of this is new or bold to say, it’s just that this opportunity, if squandered, could be catastrophic. Not to diminish the work and breadth of the win or how immensely hopeful this feels, it’s just that we can’t trust the Democrats because they have a 52-year track record of not getting enough done in moments like this. And at each diminishing turn, we’ve lurched further and further away from democracy. 

So there are quite a few historians and journalists who have written extensively about our recent slide into fascism and I thought it might be a good time to take stock of what some of them are saying in this moment and what they think we have to do. The most common thread between what Timothy Snyder, M. Gessen and Ruth Ben-Ghiat are saying is that we’re not out of the woods by any means, and we don’t have much time to mobilize. Snyder, by the way, often says that we should credit Roosevelt for saving the Republic, it’s his belief that we easily could have slid into fascism had the New Deal never happened. He also thinks we have the first six months for the new Congress to do something big. If we blow that, all of this can dissipate quickly. Gessen and Ben-Ghiat also believe that there are no guarantees that the fascists can’t regroup by 2028. And as I just mentioned, the Democrats have blown every moment like this since 1974, so my thought is that the reason that the MAGA Party has been so quiet is that they know this is too big to rig or steal, so let the momentum wane, and chances are the Democrats will screw it all up anyway. As they always do.

Another point that Snyder, Gessen and Ben-Ghiat agree on is that we have to rein in the power structure itself, that accountability and affordability and returning to a democracy are actually all intertwined. And that there is no returning to some kind of normal politics, like the kind we’ve had since 1974, that’s over. We need something big and transformative like the New Deal.

So how do we do that? 

First, we need new Congressional Leadership

The moment is here, and frankly it’s well deserved; the last thing we need is Schumer and Jeffries telling us what is and what isn’t achievable. To put it nicely, both men practice a type of politics that is outdated for our situation. And Jeffries’s failure to secure the impeachment votes for Hegseth is just confirmation that he doesn’t understand the gravity of this moment. Since the Hegseth failure, he’s been asked why he’s so confident that he’s going to be confirmed as Speaker, and his answer is that he leaves nothing to chance. Really? That’s interesting. It’s also laughable to hear Schumer on The Daily (NYT Podcast) talking about how his strategy led the way to this landslide win. Playing these delusional games is why these guys have to go, that and their whole Clintonesque New Democrats mentality. This election was not a vote for the Democratic platform as it exists today, this vote was a national cry for help. A demand for permanent change and an end to the oligarchy we’ve been living under for the past decade or so. And I would say that it was the new and old blood (call them what you will), like Talarico, El-Sayad, AOC, Warren, Sanders, Ossoff, Cesar, Mamdani and so many more, that brought the real energy and the promise to take on the wealth that is smothering our democracy. And I would also argue that it was their messaging that was resonating everywhere, and that they provided the juice that helped millions of grassroots organizers get the job done. I didn’t see Schumer or Jeffries bringing that energy. And without substantial transformational improvement in the quality of everyday people’s lives, we will not be able to end our current slide into fascism—Snyder, Ben-Ghiat and Gessen all say this. We need new leadership to meet this moment.

There’s no addressing inequality without accountability

There’s the obvious stuff we all think about. The illegal war in Iran, the family business, the crypto stuff, all the stock trading, the pay-to-play schemes, all of that is obvious and should be addressed. Wait, let me clear my throat—Hegseth-cough-Jeffries-cough—okay, I’m back. And then investigate ICE and Homeland Security, find out who gave the orders, who is blocking the investigations into the killing of Pretti and Good and so many others. Who’s behind the concentration camps and the masks and the illegal abductions? What happened with DOGE? And Elon Musk’s government contracts? What’s up with Lutnick’s relationship with Jensen Huang? All of it needs to happen.

But there’s another corruption we need to address. We can blame the Republicans and Donald Trump for the mess we are in, but really this has been a decades-long project of corporate America. They’re the real culprits here, and they own much of the Democratic Party. Big pharma, big oil, the industrial-military complex, the ten companies that produce the majority of all of the processed foods you see in grocery stores, Silicon Valley, the oligopolies that rule our agriculture, all of these industries have been chipping away at our quality of life and our Democracy for decades. It’s the fault of individuals making decisions, but it’s also built into the whole system of capitalism as it exists today. In short, we are the generation that failed to rein in our monopolies, and that has to end. That’s the core corruption at the heart of our slide into fascism. We have to address that in a way that goes even further than what Roosevelt did, and we need real, permanent restraint of big business if we’re ever going to reclaim our democracy and hold it. Roosevelt famously said he wanted to save capitalism. From what you might ask? From itself is the answer. Well, maybe it’s time to do to capitalism what Grover Norquist said should be done with government: make it small enough to drown in a bathtub. Jeez, that sounds so violent, what’s wrong with these weirdos?

We need a new One Hundred Days, and that requires an end to the filibuster

Often it has been asked what a new President will do in their first one hundred days. That is a reference to the barrage of important legislation that FDR put forward when he first became President. This Congress needs to be that aggressive. Sure, a lot won’t get past a veto, great, let the vetoes pile up. Bernie is also talking about a big reconciliation bill, those confuse people and they’re hard to message around, but sure, do all of the above. But I would say we need to do what Al Franken has been saying for years. Ban the silent filibuster, make it so the only way to filibuster is to hold the floor in debate. That basically ends the gridlock. Make these MAGA Republicans take the floor and explain for 20 hours why kids shouldn’t get SNAP, or why there shouldn’t be the healthcare subsidies they took away, or why we can’t regulate data centers. And then pass everything we need and let Trump veto it. 

On this point, Talerico has brought up an interesting possibility. And it’s all the more reason to get Miller, Vought, Lutnick and all the rest of the architects embroiled in investigations. The more they’re distracted and on the ropes, the easier it will be to get inside the deluded mind of Donald Trump. He is, after all, only interested in one thing: his own self-aggrandizement. He just has an insatiable desire for attention. Talerico thinks he might just pass some of this stuff if he can take credit for it and win adoration from the masses. But he’ll never do it with Vought and Lutnick whispering in his ears. Seems unlikely, but worth mentioning, and with this one I do hope I’m wrong about it—jeez, I can’t stop myself. Anyway, it is another reason to start the investigations immediately. But we should steer clear of Trump and family for now, there’s plenty of time to put Kushner behind bars later. He’s young. Just take out the idea men who are planning the fascist takeover and let Trump play with the drapes and have fantasies of being king.

Basically, the Democrats need to show the American people that they mean business. Just like FDR did. Small measures and tinkering around the edges are a recipe for disaster. The moment is now, and if we don’t keep constant pressure on the corporate dems and if we let them fail once again, then we’re in real trouble. So keep up the pressure; this is no time to kick back and hope for the best. Stay engaged, get involved. To paraphrase M. Gessen, what should people do? M. would say, well, do something, because whatever you can do today, you may not be able to do tomorrow. 

This is the moment, the time is now, and we’re the ones who happen to be here.

*So all of my essays are available for free on my website michaeldigioia.com dating back to 2020. I set up a Substack because I’m pitching a science fiction manuscript (you can’t call it a novel til it’s published), and to lit agents it looks better if you have some of this stuff in place. So if you like my stuff, sign up for my Substack, just do the free subscription. I generate one or two pieces a month. But also, comment, let’s dialogue there about the stuff I write about. I’ll be sure to engage.